THE HOME OF SOCIAL TV

Why don’t news sites link other sites?

Posted by Cory Bergman on November 26, 2007

I’m reading this NYTimes.com story about Deadline Hollywood Daily, a blog authored by LA Weekly’s Nikki Finke, which has become extremely popular since the writers’ strike. Now, there are various links inside the story, like Writers Guild of America and Disney. But click those links and you’re transported to other NYTimes.com stories about the same topic. Do you think somewhere — anywhere — the article links Deadline Hollywood Daily? Nope. And this is the same at the majority of newspaper and TV news sites across the country. Oh, must… not… link… off… the… site. So what does someone do after reading the story? They go to Google and type in “Deadline Hollywood Daily.” Yes, Google, the big “enemy” of media sites. How stupid.

Oh, want the link to Deadline Hollywood Daily? Here it is.

  • http://tvdecoder.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/11/20/show-chart/ discreet_chaos

    (I’m not sure if the spamfilter ate my previous comment or if it got lost in the ether. Anyway, I actually put the wrong url in the textbox, so at least this one would be right)

    I’d venture that the NYTimes may have a policy about linking to blogs, rather than outside sites.

    If you click my name, you’ll find one of Brian Stelter’s NYTimes “TVDecoder” entries which addressed the way the strike would affect many popular shows.

    All of the source links in that post point toward mainstream media sources and if you click the one beside “24″, you’re taken to a mainsite article, also written by Brian, which links to a grid from the LATimes.

    So, though I may be mistaken, I have to assume that the lack of a link in the Nikki Finke article is more reflective of the Times questioning the reliability of blogs, rather than a blanket policy against all outside links.

    (I apologize if this is a dupe. I don’t know what happened)

  • discreet_chaos

    Whoops! I should’ve clicked and actually verified my assumptions before commenting (twice)

    I now see that the “24″ article isn’t to a mainsite article, but to another “TVDecoder” post. (I could’ve sworn it was a mainsite article when I first read it, a couple of weeks ago, but I’m probably wrong) Anyway… So, my whole theory about the “reliability” of blogs has gone out the window, but any way you look at it, we can at least see that the Times might have a different linking policy for their in-house blogs, if nothing else.

    (Sorry about my confusion. I just got out of a loooong meeting and obviously didn’t think)

  • Rob

    Many news sites are still hoping you’ll ignore other news sites and click the link to ‘Make us your homepage.’

    They’re focused so much on beating the competition and holding their content close to their vests they lose site of the reason why they exist: The consumer and their wants and needs.

  • http://wcco.com/entertainment/youtube.minnesota.artists.2.414348.html Jason

    I think part of it with TV sites is that web producers re-writing reporter stories don’t take the time to go and find links and code them in. And most reporters don’t know how to code their web scripts to link.

    We typically include links in an outside column next to our stories (Related Links). Click my name to read a recent story I did on Minnesotans using YouTube: I coded the links right into the body of the story.

    It always drives me nuts when the local newspaper writes a story about a web page or web venture and doesn’t link it.

  • http://stevegarfield.com steve Garfield

    You got that right. It’s a long standing problem with the Boston Globe. In articles about YouTube they almost never link to the videos they are writing about. I usually do it for them in a blog post.

  • http://www.thepomoblog.com Terry Heaton

    The New York Times builds dynamic pages on subjects, topics and people it covers, and its CMS automatically codes the links in the stories. It does this not only to generate page view opportunities, but also to raise its Google juice in the same way that Wikipedia does. If your site doesn’t do this, your handshake with the Web is only partial.

    That said, I fully agree with Cory that outside links would be nice. However, a link FROM the Times carries enormous weight in the handshake process, and they likely figure there’s no quid pro quo. Lame.

  • Gorman

    Lame indeed. It shouldn’t be about the quid pro quo. They shouldn’t care about the traffic coming back from the places to which they link, it’ll rarely be worth it. As long as you keep the users that came to your site in the first place a better experience, in this case better informed, that should matter more.

    One of the few things I love about Wikipedia is that you have tons of cross-linking throughout an article. Normally I’ll find myself wandering through several pages, but when I come to a dead end, I always pop back to the page from which I started to wander.

    I’d have to agree with Jason, but in markets with smaller web staffs, it’s less about “making” the time than it is “having” the time to do it.

  • http://www.allyourtv.com Rick Ellis

    While I agree that the Times piece would benefit from actually linking to the site it’s discussing, not linking to other sites perceived as competiton is not unusual. For that matter, Nikki’s site generally doesn’t seem to link to sites she might consider competition.

    In the end, it’s a business decision, albeit a dumb one.

  • http://www.tvbythenumbers.com Bill Gorman

    I think it may be a distinction [meaningless on the web] between news articles and blog posts.

    Brian Stelter has linked to our blog from his TVDecoder blog posts at NYT, but perhaps that is verboten from news “articles”.

  • http://www.davidanrewjohnson.com David Johnson

    Terry has it all down in spades, as usual.

  • http://www.davidanrewjohnson.com David Johnson

    but… i think there is a potentially blurry line in associative or inline linking from article text to sites where a certain level of endorsement could be implied. or at least editors are thinking about that, which may be a good thing.

    indeed, once you get beyond the image-oriented value of branding exposure, online advertising conversion is pretty much about driving traffic to sites via clickthroughs.

    if one applies the old pr-vs-ad print rules about one inch of news copy being worth 100 times (or some other similarly giant multiple) of the same inch of display advertising, how much is an inline, contextual link in article body copy worth compared to a text ad or banner ad.

    clearly, search engines like google value them highly, and for good reason. inline hyperlinking is the fundamental value proposition behind the initial creation of hypertext markup language. and prior to search engines, it was the only way to navigate the WWW if you didn’t get a direct URL via word of mouth. this seems to also be playing out where online branding and marketing folks are trying to get bloggers to give them some link juice.

    in a revenue-challenged environment, i can see many reasons why the new york times would consider not linking from story copy a sensible practice in protecting editorial integrity and advertising value at the same time… at least for now.

  • http://stateoflocal.com/2007/11/27/online-news-consumers-are-not-depletable-resources/ Scott Wyffels

    Yep, most traditional online news sites view users as depletable resources.

  • tdc

    #12 posts the most ironic comment as their “customers” do not even provide links to their other OWNED properties.

    sorry, scott.

  • http://bathroomfurniturecabinets.co.uk Mora Benadom

    I have really enjoyied reading your well written article. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!

  • http://modularbathroomfurniture.co.uk/2010/08/nice-bathroom-photos-3 Ellsworth Loggins

    Great article but a load more pictures could make it improved

  • http://www.guysgarage.com garage milwaukee

    Thanks for your insight for the great written piece. I am glad I have taken the time to read this.

  • http://buy-phentermine-online.com buy phentermine

    Finally, an issue that I am passionate about. I’ve appeared for info of this caliber for the final several hours. Your website is significantly appreciated.

  • http://www.thomassabo-london.com/ thomas sabo jewellery

    Your article bare the true thinking of showing your true feelings between the lines, I had great insights, hoping to interact more!

  • http://phentermineusa.com phentermine 37.5

    This really answered my problem, thank you!

  • http://valium-diazepam.net buy valium

    I loved what youve done here. The design is elegant, your content classy. Yet, youve got an edginess to what youre offering here. Ill definitely come back for more if you keep this up. Dont lose hope if not too many people see your vision, know youve got a fan right here who values what youve got to say and the way youve presented yourself. Good on you!

  • http://vietlao.com.vn/diendan/index.php?action=profile;u=72469 Mauricio Wylam

    Kudos for the great article. I am glad I have taken the time to learn this.

  • http://www.hairstyles2011.org/summer-hairstyles-2011-african-american/ Summer Hairstyles 2011 African American

    Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I’m not sure about the former.

  • http://www.sonicloans.net/bad-credit-personal-loan.html Herma

    This is specifically what i was looking for. best wishes for the enlightening post and keep up the good work! Respectfully, Herma.

  • http://www.wwgggtghfjhzfzudhj.com Charles Keyt

    You made some nice points there. I did a search on the issue and found the majority of persons will have the same opinion with your blog.

  • http://www.cartuse.ro/cartus-canon-ep-e-cartus-toner-ep-e-original-canon-lbp-1260/ Cartus Canon Ep E

    Coming home from very lonely places, all of us go a little mad: whether from great personal success, or just an all-night drive, we are the sole survivors of a world no one else has ever seen.

  • http://www.cartuse.ro/cartus-hp-c4913a-cartus-yellow-nr-82-69ml-c4913a-original-hp-designjet-500/ Cartus Hp C4913A Yellow

    If at first you don’t succeed, find out if the loser gets anything.

  • http://debtfreecounselor.com Credit Debt

    I just encountered your blog and really loved it. I’m going to add a bookmark, keep up the good work!

  • http://www.celebrity-gossip.net/ Celeb Girls

    I love this blog, I found it on Google and I think I will come back one day, it very interesting for me. Thanks

  • http://www.topcoafuri.ro/rochii-pentru-cununia-civila/articole Rochii Pentru Cununia Civila

    Nobody in life gets exactly what they thought they were going to get. But if you work really hard and you’re kind, amazing things will happen.

  • http://www.bedroomfurniturediscounts.com discounted bedroom furniture

    Hi I found your blog on google and enjoyed reading it very much. I’ve bookmarked your site and will be back.

  • http://flashdrivereport.blogspot.com custom usb flash drives

    Surfing the web, I ran across this website. I am hunting for a few ideas for a design for my own blog. I like your design, did you produce or change this design? I got a website too and my design looks kinda bad so people don’t hang about on my website very long.

  • http://www.ks7w66fgg3f53f.com Laurene Rijo

    Thanks for this post, I am a big big fan of this site would like to proceed updated.

  • http://online-casinotest.com/ online casino

    The Descendants of Terah

  • http://bathroomslouth.com/2010/09/06/bathroom-cabinets-can-look-stunning Demetria Carbine

    Hey just wanted to let you know that your content is very impressive, also Youre writing is wicked!, thanks again.